We finally know what the deal is with Theo Rossi’s creepy therapist character in ‘The Penguin’

In The Penguin, Dr. Julian Rush, played by Theo Rossi, initially appears as a shadowy figure, quietly observing the chaotic environment of Arkham Asylum. His character gains depth in the pivotal episode titled “Cent’Ann,” where Sofia Falcone, portrayed by Cristin Milioti, undergoes a profound transformation as she navigates her traumatic past.

As Sofia recovers from a head injury after a confrontation with the Maronis, the episode delves into her ten-year journey at Arkham, revealing her innocence regarding the Hangman moniker attributed to her. Instead of being a violent criminal, Sofia has been subjected to brutal treatment under the oversight of her father’s corrupt psychiatrists, with Dr. Rush being the only exception in her harrowing experience.

The dynamics between Rush and Sofia become increasingly complicated as the episode progresses. When Sofia first enters Arkham, her desperate claims of being set up by her father are dismissed as paranoid delusions. However, Rush starts to see the truth in her words as he spends more time with her. Their relationship evolves, sharing a bond that dances on the edge of professional ethics. Unlike the infamous pairing of The Joker and Harley Quinn, their connection is more nuanced, rooted in a shared understanding of betrayal and the struggle against a corrupt system.

Rush’s decision to resign from Sofia’s treatment team speaks volumes about his moral compass. Unable to witness the mistreatment she endures, he becomes a reluctant ally in her quest for redemption. However, this redemption arc is fraught with complications. Rush’s intentions are often obscured by the palpable tension between them, suggesting a complex interplay of professional duty and personal feelings.

The physical interactions between Rush and Sofia hint at deeper emotional undercurrents. During their sessions, there’s an intimacy in their eye contact and touch that strays beyond therapeutic boundaries. Sofia even confronts Rush about his underlying intentions, adding layers to their relationship that go beyond mental health care. While nothing overtly inappropriate has transpired—yet—their chemistry is undeniable, making viewers question how far Rush might go to support her.

Sofia truly shines in this episode, transforming into a formidable character determined to reclaim her power. Following her recollections and revelations about her family’s betrayal—having legally declared her mentally incompetent—Sofia realizes the extent of her family’s manipulation. The men in her family underestimated her strength, and she’s ready to take back control, setting the stage for a potential reckoning within the Falcone organization.

As the series unfolds, Rush’s role remains uncertain, but one thing is clear: the journey ahead will be fraught with tension, moral dilemmas, and thrilling developments as Sofia rises from the ashes of her past. The exploration of her character not only captivates but also suggests a shift in the narrative focus, hinting that The Penguin may very well transition into a showcase for Sofia Falcone’s strength and resilience.