Is ‘The Substance’ completely right about aging?

Advertisement

The Substance, directed by Coralie Fargeat, dives deep into the dark side of Hollywood’s obsession with youth and beauty through a shocking body-horror lens. The film features Demi Moore as Elisabeth, a once-glamorous actress who, in a desperate bid to reclaim her career, takes a mysterious serum that allows her to give birth to a younger version of herself, Sue, played by Margaret Qualley. This premise leads to a disturbing exploration of identity, aging, and societal expectations, ultimately culminating in a bizarre and violent climax.

Fargeat’s direction is visually striking, with each frame crafted to evoke discomfort. The film employs jarring sound design, where everyday noises become amplified, and the camera never settles, creating an atmosphere of unease. Moore and Qualley’s performances are raw and fearless, displaying their characters’ emotional and physical extremes. However, the film’s central conceit—a woman willingly sacrificing her life for a chance at youth—raises questions about its plausibility, especially given Moore’s striking beauty at 62.

The film opens with Elisabeth’s star on the Walk of Fame, a symbol of her past glory, only to be overshadowed by her struggles with aging and Hollywood’s relentless standards. After being fired for being “too old,” she is led to the serum, a decision that feels extreme even within the context of a society obsessed with youth. The mechanics of the serum’s effects are grotesque: Elisabeth transforms, giving rise to Sue, who then experiences life in the limelight while Elisabeth languishes in a state of neglect.

As Sue’s character evolves, she becomes increasingly monstrous, leading to a climax that features a horrifying transformation and an explosive act of violence during a televised New Year’s show. Fargeat articulates a powerful message about the complicity of the audience in perpetuating these beauty standards, suggesting that the violence inflicted upon women by societal expectations can, in turn, be projected back onto the audience.

The film’s ending, marked by a dramatic blood-splattering scene, symbolizes the culmination of this cycle of violence and exploitation. Both characters experience a loss of agency, highlighting the horror of a woman’s quest for validation in a world that prizes youth above all else. While The Substance is visually arresting and thematically provocative, it ultimately challenges viewers to consider the price of beauty and the grotesque realities of aging in a culture that demands perfection.