ABC passing on these 5 candidates for the next Bachelor/ette is a new level of outrageous
Last updated
The Bachelor franchise has certainly produced its share of memorable characters, both loved and hated, but it’s the fan favorites who often leave us wondering why they didn’t get their chance to lead a season as The Bachelor or The Bachelorette. Here are five standout individuals from the franchise who, in the eyes of many, deserved their moment in the spotlight:
1. Jonathon Johnson — The Bachelorette Season 21
Jonathon, a 28-year-old creative director from Kansas City, made quite an impression during Jenn Tran’s season. His quirky personality, which included doing crossword puzzles in the mansion and meticulously ranking Jenn’s dresses, won hearts across America. Many fans were left scratching their heads when Grant was chosen as the next Bachelor instead of Jonathon, who genuinely seems ready for love. With the upcoming season of Bachelor in Paradise, fans hope to see him find his match.
2. Blake Moynes — The Bachelorette Seasons 16 and 17, Bachelor in Paradise Season 9
Blake has become a staple in the Bachelor franchise, appearing across three seasons and even getting engaged to Katie Thurston in Season 17. While he seems destined to be the Bachelor at some point, many fans are rooting for a romance between Blake and Rachel Recchia, seeing them as a stunning couple. Regardless of where he ends up, Blake remains a fan favorite.
3. Maria Georgas — The Bachelor Season 28
Maria’s time on Joey Graziadei’s season was nothing short of polarizing. Known for her outspoken nature, she generated a lot of buzz, sparking a “Maria for Bachelorette” campaign among fans. Many believe that her presence would have ensured a drama-filled and entertaining season, so her not being selected as the next Bachelorette was a major oversight by production. However, there’s always Bachelor in Paradise!
4. Susan Noles — The Golden Bachelor Season 1
Susan, a 67-year-old wedding officiant, charmed viewers with her vivacious spirit during the inaugural season of The Golden Bachelor. After being eliminated in week five, fans were heartbroken, and many saw her as the perfect candidate for the first Golden Bachelorette. Though she didn’t get that title—going to Joan Vassos instead—Susan has since teamed up with fellow contestant Kathy Swarts to host the Bachelor Happy Hour: Golden Hour podcast, keeping her in the spotlight.
5. “Grocery Store” Joe Amabile — The Bachelorette Season 14, Bachelor in Paradise Seasons 5 and 7
Joe, who became a fan favorite for his down-to-earth charm, was eliminated on the first night of Becca Kufrin’s season, leading to an uproar from viewers and a “Joe for Bachelor” movement. Though he didn’t get the lead role, he found love on Bachelor in Paradise Season 7 with Serena Pitt, and the two have since married and even co-host a podcast together. His story is a heartwarming reminder that love can blossom in unexpected ways.
As the franchise continues to evolve, it’s uncertain whether any of these beloved figures will ever get their chance to shine as the lead. Past seasons have shown that production isn’t afraid to revisit former contestants, as seen with Arie Luyendyk Jr., Nick Viall, and Clare Crawley. Until then, fans can catch the latest episodes of Dancing with the Stars, featuring former Bachelors and Bachelorettes, and keep an eye on the ongoing season of The Golden Bachelorette. With so much talent in Bachelor Nation, there’s no shortage of intriguing personalities to follow!
